placestats

Productivity (TFP)

Total factor productivity level, compared with the US (Penn World Table)

Link with national income+0.79strongly income-linked
Links that hold up4of 193 pairs tested
Unitratio to the US (US = 1)higher is better
SourcePenn World TableCC BY 4.0
What this measures. Total factor productivity (TFP) is how much a country produces compared with what its workers, their schooling, and its machines and buildings would be expected to produce. It is the part of GDP that those inputs do not account for, such as better technology or better organisation. The US is set to 1 in every year, so 0.5 means a country gets about half as much output from the same inputs as the US. It is worked out from GDP, capital, the number of workers, their schooling and the labor share, so it is linked to each of them by arithmetic. It is left out of the economy score: being built from GDP, it would turn that score back into GDP per person.

How it has moved

Loading…

Countries With the Highest Productivity (TFP) · Countries With the Lowest Productivity (TFP)

Every country, every year

One row per country and one column per year, sorted by the most recent value. Hover over any cell to see the figure. The country names link to each country’s page.

Loading…

Links that hold up

r is how closely two measures rise and fall together across countries, from −1 (opposite) to +1 (in step), where 0 means no link. These pairs are ranked by the link after adjusting for national income, which means comparing countries with the same GDP per person. Each pair passed three checks. The link held after that adjustment. It was unlikely to be chance (q of 0.05 or less), even allowing for countries in the same region being alike and for the many pairs tested. And the two are not just two measures of the same thing. Very small q values are written in short form: 8.0e-5 means 0.000080.

MeasureBefore adjustingAfter adjustingqCountriesTracks income?
Productivity (TFP) and Unintended pregnancies ending in abortionWhere Productivity (TFP) is higher, Unintended pregnancies ending in abortion tends to be lower: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Unintended pregnancies ending in abortion by country-0.15-0.380.00796independent
Productivity (TFP) and Recycling rateComparing only countries with similar income, Recycling rate tends to be lower where Productivity (TFP) is higher: the opposite of the unadjusted figure, which only showed the income gap between countries. Recycling rate by country+0.10-0.340.02335moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Hours workedWhere Productivity (TFP) is higher, Hours worked tends to be lower: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Hours worked by country-0.58-0.240.04938high
Productivity (TFP) and East Asian ancestryWhere Productivity (TFP) is higher, East Asian ancestry tends to be lower: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. East Asian ancestry by country-0.05-0.220.006114independent

Links that don’t count as findings

These go together strongly, but they are built from the same numbers or measure the same thing. So they are bound to match, or their match shows that the measures agree, not something about the world.

MeasureBefore adjustingAfter adjustingqCountriesTracks income?
Productivity (TFP) and Investment share of GDPNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Investment share of GDP by country+0.09-0.370.102118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Gender Development IndexNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Gender Development Index by country+0.29-0.330.026116high
Productivity (TFP) and Inequality-adjusted HDINot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Inequality-adjusted HDI by country+0.70-0.210.236112proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Human capital (PWT)Not an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Human capital (PWT) by country+0.57-0.180.416118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Capital per workerNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Capital per worker by country+0.59-0.140.403118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Mean years of schoolingNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Mean years of schooling by country+0.61-0.120.670117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Education scoreNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Education score by country+0.62-0.110.609118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Labor share of incomeNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Labor share of income by country+0.01-0.030.781118independent
Productivity (TFP) and HDINot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. HDI by country+0.74-0.020.946117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Price levelNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Price level by country+0.54-0.001.000118high

How much the other measures account for

The 72 most widely reported measures boil down to a few broad patterns. This table shows how much of the differences between countries on this measure those patterns account for, adding one pattern at a time. The patterns are rebuilt without this measure, and without anything built from the same numbers or measuring the same thing. So it never predicts itself under another name. The figures use the 99 countries reporting all of them, and 68 candidate measures.

This shows how much it moves with the others. It does not explain anything. Measures that move together end up on the same pattern whether or not anything connects them. And the countries here are the best-documented ones. A high figure means this measure is largely predictable from the others, not that they produce it.
Patterns usedShare of this measure accounted forAdded by this pattern
153%—
253%+0%
355%+1%
456%+1%
557%+1%
657%+0%

How it differs by category

This compares the measure across groups of countries, such as those sharing a main religion, instead of against another number. The figure is the share of the differences between countries on this measure that lies between the groups, on a scale from 0 to 1. It is shown before and after adjusting for national income.

The “between groups” figure runs from 0 (the groups are no different) to 1 (the groups explain all the differences between countries). Groups have no up or down, so this says how much the groups differ, never which way. For that, read the group averages. The figure also tends to rise when there are more groups. So to judge whether it could be chance (q), we shuffle the same labels among the same countries many times and see how often a figure this big turns up. Then we allow for the fact that many measures are checked at once, since with enough checks a few big figures turn up by luck alone. Groups with fewer than 12 countries are left out. And countries that share a label share a lot else. Adjusting for income rules out one third factor, but leaves language, region, legal tradition and history untouched.

Grouped byBetween groupsAfter incomeqGroups at each end
Last European coloniser0.230.170.616best: United Kingdom 0.607 · worst: France 0.474
ratio to the US (US = 1)
Largest religious group0.120.050.665best: Christians 0.636 · worst: Muslims 0.572
ratio to the US (US = 1)
Official ideology0.210.160.282best: No strong official ideology 0.658 · worst: Nationalist 0.528
ratio to the US (US = 1)
Party system0.250.080.661best: No parties banned 0.652 · worst: A few parties banned 0.494
ratio to the US (US = 1)

Every other pair

Everything else this measure was tested against, apart from the links that hold up and the pairs built from the same numbers. Sorted by the link after adjusting. Search by name; every column sorts. A small adjusted figure is a result too. It says the two do not move together once income is set aside.

178 of 178
Productivity (TFP) and Aid givenLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.38) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Aid given by country+0.57+0.380.20645high
Productivity (TFP) and Frequent prayerCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Frequent prayer by country-0.30+0.320.34360high
Productivity (TFP) and Women in managementAlmost no link either way. Women in management by country-0.01-0.310.166100moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Gender wage gapCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender wage gap by country-0.29-0.300.24938independent
Productivity (TFP) and Marriage rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Marriage rate by country-0.27-0.290.07746independent
Productivity (TFP) and CO2 per capitaCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. CO2 per capita by country+0.27-0.270.328117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Births outside marriageAlmost no link either way. Births outside marriage by country+0.07+0.270.41743independent
Productivity (TFP) and Public order spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Public order spending by country-0.30+0.260.33137high
Productivity (TFP) and Population 0-14Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.25) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Population 0-14 by country-0.60+0.250.135118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Military spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Military spending by country-0.11-0.250.292115independent
Productivity (TFP) and Hours worked (PWT)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Hours worked (PWT) by country-0.50-0.240.170101moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Market-income GiniCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Market-income Gini by country-0.19+0.240.21845moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Primary completionLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.24) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Primary completion by country+0.50-0.240.297110proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Male labor participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Male labor participation by country-0.24-0.240.400118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Birth rateLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.23) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Birth rate by country-0.59+0.230.269118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Female labor participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Female labor participation by country-0.12-0.220.370118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Sound money (Fraser)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Sound money (Fraser) by country+0.25-0.220.249117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Abortion rate (legal, reported)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Abortion rate (legal, reported) by country+0.11+0.210.47738independent
Productivity (TFP) and Retirement age, womenAlmost no link either way. Retirement age, women by country+0.05+0.210.60649independent
Productivity (TFP) and UnemploymentAlmost no link either way. Unemployment by country+0.04+0.210.303118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Fertility rateLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.20) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Fertility rate by country-0.57+0.200.330118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Hospital bedsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Hospital beds by country+0.25-0.200.326110high
Productivity (TFP) and Abortion rate (estimate)Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.20) could easily be chance. Abortion rate (estimate) by country-0.51-0.200.21496moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Adult literacyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Adult literacy by country+0.45-0.190.25978high
Productivity (TFP) and Labour scoreLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.19) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Labour score by country+0.50-0.190.120118high
Productivity (TFP) and Education spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Education spending by country+0.18+0.190.148115independent
Productivity (TFP) and Unemployment benefit spendingAlmost no link either way. Unemployment benefit spending by country+0.01-0.190.24439moderate
Productivity (TFP) and RedistributionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Redistribution by country+0.37-0.180.44345moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Slum share of urban populationLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.18) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Slum share of urban population by country-0.53+0.180.429114high
Productivity (TFP) and ResearchersLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.18) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Researchers by country+0.61+0.180.210100proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Infant mortalityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.17) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Infant mortality by country-0.57+0.170.298116proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Food insecurityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.17) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Food insecurity by country-0.58+0.170.222101proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Interpersonal trustLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.17) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Interpersonal trust by country+0.54+0.170.16084high
Productivity (TFP) and Small government (Fraser)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Small government (Fraser) by country-0.32-0.170.221117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Median ageLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.17) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Median age by country+0.59-0.170.353118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Expected schoolingLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.16) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Expected schooling by country+0.69+0.160.276117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Control of corruptionLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.16) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Control of corruption by country+0.64+0.160.537118high
Productivity (TFP) and Participatory democracyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Participatory democracy by country+0.48+0.160.383117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Internet usersLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.16) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Internet users by country+0.64-0.160.369118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Under-5 mortalityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.16) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Under-5 mortality by country-0.56+0.160.415116proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Children with one parentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Children with one parent by country+0.19+0.160.48538independent
Productivity (TFP) and Electricity accessLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.16) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Electricity access by country+0.54-0.160.579118high
Productivity (TFP) and Corruption Perceptions IndexLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.15) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Corruption Perceptions Index by country+0.62+0.150.463117high
Productivity (TFP) and Official ideology, strengthCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Official ideology, strength by country-0.26-0.150.305117independent
Productivity (TFP) and African ancestryLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.15) could easily be chance. African ancestry by country-0.50+0.150.526114moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Economic freedom (Fraser)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Economic freedom (Fraser) by country+0.46-0.150.415117high
Productivity (TFP) and Health coverage indexLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.15) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Health coverage index by country+0.61-0.150.432116proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Political stabilityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political stability by country+0.46-0.150.255118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Anaemia in womenCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Anaemia in women by country-0.44+0.150.574115high
Productivity (TFP) and Basic water accessLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.15) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Basic water access by country+0.59-0.150.604117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Health spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Health spending by country+0.35+0.140.292116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Political corruptionLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.14) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Political corruption by country-0.57-0.140.469117high
Productivity (TFP) and Basic sanitationLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.14) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Basic sanitation by country+0.56-0.140.595117high
Productivity (TFP) and Liberal democracyLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.14) could easily be chance. Liberal democracy by country+0.52+0.140.445117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Rule of lawLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.14) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Rule of law by country+0.66+0.140.498118high
Productivity (TFP) and Freedom of expressionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Freedom of expression by country+0.33+0.140.432117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Family benefits spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Family benefits spending by country+0.13-0.130.24642independent
Productivity (TFP) and Public social spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Public social spending by country+0.23-0.130.26942moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Freedom to trade (Fraser)Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.13) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Freedom to trade (Fraser) by country+0.50-0.130.389117high
Productivity (TFP) and Civil society participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Civil society participation by country+0.30+0.130.487117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Women ministersCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women ministers by country+0.23+0.130.346116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Government spending per capitaLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.13) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Government spending per capita by country+0.55-0.130.47743proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Migrant share of populationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Migrant share of population by country+0.39-0.130.688118high
Productivity (TFP) and Youth not in work or studyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Youth not in work or study by country-0.44+0.130.334112high
Productivity (TFP) and Unintended pregnancy rateLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.12) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Unintended pregnancy rate by country-0.52+0.120.57096high
Productivity (TFP) and Forest areaAlmost no link either way. Forest area by country-0.04-0.120.134116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Conflict deathsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Conflict deaths by country-0.19-0.120.576116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Primary enrollmentAlmost no link either way. Primary enrollment by country+0.05+0.120.289117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Age at childbearingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Age at childbearing by country+0.50+0.120.538118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Extreme poverty rateLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.12) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Extreme poverty rate by country-0.55+0.120.657110proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Regime typeCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Regime type by country+0.45+0.120.631117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Voice and accountabilityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.12) could easily be chance. Voice and accountability by country+0.54+0.120.513118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Muslim shareCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Muslim share by country-0.14+0.120.138118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Single-parent householdsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Single-parent households by country-0.16-0.120.43099independent
Productivity (TFP) and Governing party, economic left to rightCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Governing party, economic left to right by country+0.12+0.110.241109independent
Productivity (TFP) and Electoral democracyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Electoral democracy by country+0.46+0.110.574117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Pupil-teacher ratioLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.11) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Pupil-teacher ratio by country-0.61+0.110.499112proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Old-age spendingAlmost no link either way. Old-age spending by country+0.04-0.110.35242independent
Productivity (TFP) and PISA readingLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.11) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. PISA reading by country+0.61+0.110.73773high
Productivity (TFP) and Refugees originatingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Refugees originating by country-0.30-0.110.508117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Political civil libertiesCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political civil liberties by country+0.33+0.110.520117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Pre-trial detainee shareCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Pre-trial detainee share by country-0.28-0.110.458112independent
Productivity (TFP) and Protected landAlmost no link either way. Protected land by country+0.05-0.110.457117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Divorce rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Divorce rate by country-0.15-0.110.80345independent
Productivity (TFP) and Life satisfactionLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.11) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Life satisfaction by country+0.56-0.110.535115proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Religious attendanceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Religious attendance by country-0.46+0.100.57182high
Productivity (TFP) and Adolescent fertilityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.10) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Adolescent fertility by country-0.58+0.100.545118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and PhysiciansLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (-0.10) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Physicians by country+0.56-0.100.463116proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Women's age at first marriage (census-based)Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.10) could easily be chance. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Women's age at first marriage (census-based) by country+0.63+0.100.548115high
Productivity (TFP) and Homicide rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Homicide rate by country-0.27-0.100.534107moderate
Productivity (TFP) and HIV prevalenceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. HIV prevalence by country-0.19+0.100.43997moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Indigenous American ancestryCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Indigenous American ancestry by country-0.12-0.100.153114independent
Productivity (TFP) and Corporate tax rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Corporate tax rate by country-0.16+0.100.52671moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Marriage rate (UN)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Marriage rate (UN) by country-0.14+0.100.82475independent
Productivity (TFP) and Women in parliamentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women in parliament by country+0.12+0.100.526116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Infrastructure scoreLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Infrastructure score by country+0.68-0.100.713118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Compulsory schoolingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Compulsory schooling by country+0.27+0.100.399113moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Governance scoreLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Governance score by country+0.56+0.090.615117high
Productivity (TFP) and Retirement age, menCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Retirement age, men by country-0.16+0.090.79349independent
Productivity (TFP) and Ease of forming a partyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Ease of forming a party by country+0.25+0.090.679117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Gender Inequality IndexLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Gender Inequality Index by country-0.63+0.090.464114proxy
Productivity (TFP) and InflationAlmost no link either way. Inflation by country-0.07+0.090.514118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Religion very importantCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Religion very important by country-0.41+0.090.60384high
Productivity (TFP) and Economy free of state ownershipCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Economy free of state ownership by country+0.27+0.090.502117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Armed conflict presentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Armed conflict present by country-0.38-0.090.610116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Equality scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Equality score by country+0.49-0.090.748110high
Productivity (TFP) and Environment scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Environment score by country-0.25-0.090.377117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Women's age at first marriageCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women's age at first marriage by country+0.20-0.090.77040moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Health scoreAlmost no link either way. Health score by country+0.09-0.090.733116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Life expectancyLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Life expectancy by country+0.65-0.080.264118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and UndernourishmentLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Undernourishment by country-0.52+0.080.322110proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Legal system and property rights (Fraser)Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Legal system and property rights (Fraser) by country+0.63+0.080.709117proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Independent oppositionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Independent opposition by country+0.36+0.080.726116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Government effectivenessLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Government effectiveness by country+0.67+0.080.703118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Active labour market spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Active labour market spending by country+0.37+0.080.51842moderate
Productivity (TFP) and UrbanizationLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Urbanization by country+0.54-0.080.761118high
Productivity (TFP) and Freedom of associationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Freedom of association by country+0.31+0.080.722117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Religiously unaffiliatedCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Religiously unaffiliated by country+0.33-0.070.488118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Confidence in religious institutionsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Confidence in religious institutions by country-0.41-0.070.58684moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Free and fair electionsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Free and fair elections by country+0.50+0.070.678117high
Productivity (TFP) and Tobacco useCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Tobacco use by country+0.25-0.070.796107independent
Productivity (TFP) and Out-of-pocket health spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Out-of-pocket health spending by country-0.37-0.070.801116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Trade opennessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Trade openness by country+0.30-0.070.418112moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Middle Eastern ancestryCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Middle Eastern ancestry by country+0.12+0.070.273114independent
Productivity (TFP) and Tuberculosis incidenceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Tuberculosis incidence by country-0.44-0.070.732118high
Productivity (TFP) and Skilled birth attendanceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Skilled birth attendance by country+0.48-0.070.797109high
Productivity (TFP) and GDP growthCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. GDP growth by country-0.29-0.060.689118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Wellbeing scoreLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Wellbeing score by country+0.58+0.060.82784high
Productivity (TFP) and Regulatory qualityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Regulatory quality by country+0.64+0.060.823118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Government consumptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government consumption by country+0.16-0.060.670113independent
Productivity (TFP) and Civil liberties (FH)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Civil liberties (FH) by country-0.48-0.060.700117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Freedom from party bansCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Freedom from party bans by country+0.20+0.060.826117independent
Productivity (TFP) and Government expenseCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government expense by country+0.33-0.060.798106moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Alcohol consumptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Alcohol consumption by country+0.39+0.060.391116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and PISA mathsLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. PISA maths by country+0.55-0.050.91373high
Productivity (TFP) and Agricultural landCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Agricultural land by country-0.19+0.050.746117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Property rightsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Property rights by country+0.42+0.050.824117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Premature NCD mortalityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Premature NCD mortality by country-0.48+0.050.769116high
Productivity (TFP) and Secondary enrollmentLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Secondary enrollment by country+0.65+0.050.685117high
Productivity (TFP) and European ancestryCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. European ancestry by country+0.47+0.050.862114moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Mobile subscriptionsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Mobile subscriptions by country+0.28+0.040.802118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Political rights (FH)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political rights (FH) by country-0.45-0.040.827117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and FDI inflowsAlmost no link either way. FDI inflows by country-0.03-0.040.422118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Gender scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender score by country+0.22+0.040.805116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and PISA scienceLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. PISA science by country+0.58+0.040.92273high
Productivity (TFP) and Divorce rate (UN)Almost no link either way. Divorce rate (UN) by country-0.01+0.040.92669independent
Productivity (TFP) and Gini indexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gini index by country-0.28+0.040.867110moderate
Productivity (TFP) and DTP3 immunisationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. DTP3 immunisation by country+0.36-0.030.805116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Adult obesityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Adult obesity by country+0.29+0.030.915116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Contraceptive use (any method)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Contraceptive use (any method) by country+0.43-0.030.91993moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Birth registrationLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Birth registration by country+0.51-0.030.894110proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Tertiary enrollmentLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Tertiary enrollment by country+0.58-0.030.877114high
Productivity (TFP) and One-person householdsLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. One-person households by country+0.53+0.030.85899high
Productivity (TFP) and Trust in governmentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Trust in government by country+0.23+0.030.74847moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Vulnerable employmentLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Vulnerable employment by country-0.66-0.030.899118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Population growthCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Population growth by country-0.37+0.020.925118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Women's political empowermentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women's political empowerment by country+0.29-0.020.879117moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Informal employmentLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Informal employment by country-0.72-0.020.95594proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Population 65+Linked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Population 65+ by country+0.55-0.020.926118high
Productivity (TFP) and South Asian ancestryAlmost no link either way. South Asian ancestry by country+0.01+0.020.914114independent
Productivity (TFP) and Electricity use per personCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Electricity use per person by country+0.46-0.020.930118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Christian shareAlmost no link either way. Christian share by country-0.02-0.020.931118independent
Productivity (TFP) and Tax revenueCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Tax revenue by country+0.21+0.020.922106moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Contraceptive use (modern methods)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Contraceptive use (modern methods) by country+0.39+0.010.96790moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Married by 18Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Married by 18 by country-0.49-0.010.95080moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Out of school, primaryCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Out of school, primary by country-0.46-0.010.927116moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Women in a unionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women in a union by country-0.29-0.010.951118moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Child stuntingLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Child stunting by country-0.59-0.010.97496proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Fixed broadbandLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Fixed broadband by country+0.64+0.010.932118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Road traffic deathsLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Road traffic deaths by country-0.55+0.010.953116high
Productivity (TFP) and Ethnic diversityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Ethnic diversity by country-0.31+0.010.973107moderate
Productivity (TFP) and Maternal mortalityLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Maternal mortality by country-0.52+0.010.980116proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Light regulation (Fraser)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Light regulation (Fraser) by country+0.44-0.010.988117high
Productivity (TFP) and Employment in agricultureLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, almost nothing remains. Both mostly measure national income in another way, so only the adjusted figure is worth reading. Employment in agriculture by country-0.66+0.000.984118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and Suicide rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Suicide rate by country+0.17-0.000.988116independent
Productivity (TFP) and Self-reported happinessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Self-reported happiness by country+0.31-0.000.99784moderate
Productivity (TFP) and GNI per capita (PPP)One side of this pair is national income itself, the thing the other figures adjust for. Adjusting income for income leaves nothing, so there is no adjusted figure. The unadjusted link shows how closely the other measure follows income. GNI per capita (PPP) by country+0.68——118proxy
Productivity (TFP) and GDP per capita (market)One side of this pair is national income itself, the thing the other figures adjust for. Adjusting income for income leaves nothing, so there is no adjusted figure. The unadjusted link shows how closely the other measure follows income. GDP per capita (market) by country+0.66——118proxy

Source

Groningen Growth and Development Centre, University of Groningen · via DataverseNL

CC BY 4.0 · licence terms · updated irregular (new versions every few years)

Feenstra, Robert C., Robert Inklaar and Marcel P. Timmer (2015), "The Next Generation of the Penn World Table", American Economic Review, 105(10), 3150-3182, www.ggdc.net/pwt. Data: Penn World Table version 11.0, Groningen Growth and Development Centre, doi:10.34894/FABVLR.