placestats

Active labour market spending

Public spending on active labour market programmes

Link with national income+0.54partly income-linked
Links that hold up8of 155 pairs tested
Unit% of GDPhigher is neither better nor worse
SourceOECDCC BY 4.0 (OECD terms and conditions)
What this measures. Training, help finding jobs, wage subsidies and jobs created by government: spending on getting people into work rather than supporting them while out of it.

How it has moved

Loading…

Every country, every year

One row per country and one column per year, sorted by the most recent value. Hover over any cell to see the figure. The country names link to each country’s page.

Loading…

Links that hold up

r is how closely two measures rise and fall together across countries, from −1 (opposite) to +1 (in step), where 0 means no link. These pairs are ranked by the link after adjusting for national income, which means comparing countries with the same GDP per person. Each pair passed three checks. The link held after that adjustment. It was unlikely to be chance (q of 0.05 or less), even allowing for countries in the same region being alike and for the many pairs tested. And the two are not just two measures of the same thing. Very small q values are written in short form: 8.0e-5 means 0.000080.

MeasureBefore adjustingAfter adjustingqCountriesTracks income?
Active labour market spending and Secondary enrollmentWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Secondary enrollment tends to be higher: a moderate link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Secondary enrollment by country+0.54+0.470.01742high
Active labour market spending and Primary enrollmentWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Primary enrollment tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Primary enrollment by country+0.18+0.360.04142independent
Active labour market spending and Hours workedWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Hours worked tends to be lower: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Hours worked by country-0.56-0.340.01236high
Active labour market spending and Liberal democracyWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Liberal democracy tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Liberal democracy by country+0.48+0.300.04742moderate
Active labour market spending and Freedom of expressionWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Freedom of expression tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Freedom of expression by country+0.42+0.280.03042moderate
Active labour market spending and Political civil libertiesWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Political civil liberties tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Political civil liberties by country+0.41+0.260.03642moderate
Active labour market spending and Electoral democracyWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Electoral democracy tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Electoral democracy by country+0.43+0.250.04942moderate
Active labour market spending and Participatory democracyWhere Active labour market spending is higher, Participatory democracy tends to be higher: a weak link that holds when only countries with similar income are compared. Participatory democracy by country+0.42+0.230.04042moderate

Links that don’t count as findings

These go together strongly, but they are built from the same numbers or measure the same thing. So they are bound to match, or their match shows that the measures agree, not something about the world.

MeasureBefore adjustingAfter adjustingqCountriesTracks income?
Active labour market spending and Public social spendingNot an independent finding: one of these indices is built partly from the other, so their agreement is just arithmetic. Public social spending by country+0.46+0.310.05242moderate

How much the other measures account for

The 71 most widely reported measures boil down to a few broad patterns. This table shows how much of the differences between countries on this measure those patterns account for, adding one pattern at a time. The patterns are rebuilt without this measure, and without anything built from the same numbers or measuring the same thing. So it never predicts itself under another name. The figures use the 41 countries reporting all of them, and 71 candidate measures.

This shows how much it moves with the others. It does not explain anything. Measures that move together end up on the same pattern whether or not anything connects them. And the countries here are the best-documented ones. A high figure means this measure is largely predictable from the others, not that they produce it.
Patterns usedShare of this measure accounted forAdded by this pattern
121%—
222%+1%
322%+0%
424%+2%
527%+3%
639%+13%

Every other pair

Everything else this measure was tested against, apart from the links that hold up and the pairs built from the same numbers. Sorted by the link after adjusting. Search by name; every column sorts. A small adjusted figure is a result too. It says the two do not move together once income is set aside.

146 of 146
Active labour market spending and Women's age at first marriageComparing only countries with similar income it is still +0.43, but that could easily be chance once we allow for countries in the same region being alike. Women's age at first marriage by country+0.56+0.430.05739moderate
Active labour market spending and Adult obesityComparing only countries with similar income it is still -0.42, but that could easily be chance once we allow for countries in the same region being alike. Adult obesity by country-0.52-0.420.17142moderate
Active labour market spending and CO2 per capitaAlmost no link either way. CO2 per capita by country-0.06-0.400.37942proxy
Active labour market spending and Tax revenueCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Tax revenue by country+0.41+0.330.18541moderate
Active labour market spending and ResearchersLinked across countries, but mostly as richer countries differ from poorer ones: comparing only countries with similar income, what remains (+0.32) could easily be chance. Researchers by country+0.52+0.320.11940proxy
Active labour market spending and Old-age spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Old-age spending by country+0.34+0.300.06942independent
Active labour market spending and Retirement age, womenCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Retirement age, women by country-0.29-0.290.28139independent
Active labour market spending and Births outside marriageCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Births outside marriage by country+0.21+0.290.19440independent
Active labour market spending and Women's political empowermentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women's political empowerment by country+0.42+0.280.09742moderate
Active labour market spending and Youth not in work or studyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Youth not in work or study by country-0.49-0.270.12241high
Active labour market spending and Regime typeCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Regime type by country+0.44+0.270.19242moderate
Active labour market spending and Government consumptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government consumption by country+0.36+0.260.10542independent
Active labour market spending and Aid givenCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Aid given by country+0.45+0.260.46037high
Active labour market spending and Women in parliamentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women in parliament by country+0.25+0.260.08542independent
Active labour market spending and Voice and accountabilityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Voice and accountability by country+0.49+0.260.07542moderate
Active labour market spending and Interpersonal trustCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Interpersonal trust by country+0.48+0.260.20040high
Active labour market spending and Freedom of associationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Freedom of association by country+0.40+0.250.11242moderate
Active labour market spending and Mean years of schoolingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Mean years of schooling by country+0.11-0.250.14142proxy
Active labour market spending and Single-parent householdsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Single-parent households by country-0.38-0.250.21834independent
Active labour market spending and RedistributionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Redistribution by country+0.40+0.240.38640moderate
Active labour market spending and Retirement age, menCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Retirement age, men by country-0.31-0.240.41239independent
Active labour market spending and Civil society participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Civil society participation by country+0.44+0.230.18242independent
Active labour market spending and Health coverage indexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Health coverage index by country+0.11-0.230.38642proxy
Active labour market spending and PhysiciansCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Physicians by country+0.36+0.230.09242proxy
Active labour market spending and Family benefits spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Family benefits spending by country+0.35+0.230.42342independent
Active labour market spending and Education spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Education spending by country+0.27+0.230.20042independent
Active labour market spending and Governance scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Governance score by country+0.42+0.220.05742moderate
Active labour market spending and Health scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Health score by country+0.41+0.220.15242moderate
Active labour market spending and UnemploymentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Unemployment by country+0.12+0.220.18742independent
Active labour market spending and Political rights (FH)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political rights (FH) by country-0.39-0.210.14542moderate
Active labour market spending and Gender Inequality IndexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender Inequality Index by country-0.49-0.210.34742proxy
Active labour market spending and Pre-trial detainee shareCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Pre-trial detainee share by country-0.10-0.200.15941independent
Active labour market spending and Population 65+Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Population 65+ by country+0.34+0.200.10142high
Active labour market spending and InflationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Inflation by country-0.25-0.200.18242independent
Active labour market spending and Median ageCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Median age by country+0.33+0.200.25342proxy
Active labour market spending and Civil liberties (FH)Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Civil liberties (FH) by country-0.39-0.190.23842moderate
Active labour market spending and Christian shareAlmost no link either way. Christian share by country+0.06+0.190.46242independent
Active labour market spending and Trade opennessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Trade openness by country+0.38+0.190.59542moderate
Active labour market spending and GDP growthCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. GDP growth by country+0.21+0.190.05442moderate
Active labour market spending and Religion very importantCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Religion very important by country-0.39-0.190.43240high
Active labour market spending and Corruption Perceptions IndexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Corruption Perceptions Index by country+0.47+0.180.45842high
Active labour market spending and Government expenseCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government expense by country+0.18+0.180.53142moderate
Active labour market spending and Control of corruptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Control of corruption by country+0.47+0.180.26842high
Active labour market spending and Extreme poverty rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Extreme poverty rate by country-0.16+0.180.64841proxy
Active labour market spending and Population 0-14Could easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Population 0-14 by country-0.31-0.180.40342proxy
Active labour market spending and Rule of lawCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Rule of law by country+0.47+0.180.21442high
Active labour market spending and Wellbeing scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Wellbeing score by country+0.43+0.180.26240high
Active labour market spending and Expected schoolingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Expected schooling by country+0.32+0.180.27142proxy
Active labour market spending and Divorce rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Divorce rate by country-0.19-0.170.08541independent
Active labour market spending and Agricultural landCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Agricultural land by country+0.20+0.170.14942independent
Active labour market spending and Marriage rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Marriage rate by country-0.12-0.170.29441independent
Active labour market spending and Basic sanitationAlmost no link either way. Basic sanitation by country+0.05-0.170.19842high
Active labour market spending and Road traffic deathsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Road traffic deaths by country-0.45-0.160.63642high
Active labour market spending and Tobacco useCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Tobacco use by country+0.12+0.160.42942independent
Active labour market spending and Public order spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Public order spending by country-0.37-0.150.28137high
Active labour market spending and PISA readingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. PISA reading by country+0.21-0.150.46742high
Active labour market spending and Military spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Military spending by country-0.20-0.150.63840independent
Active labour market spending and Labour scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Labour score by country+0.22-0.150.56942high
Active labour market spending and Skilled birth attendanceAlmost no link either way. Skilled birth attendance by country-0.04-0.140.31335high
Active labour market spending and Religious attendanceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Religious attendance by country-0.32-0.140.39440high
Active labour market spending and Gender scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender score by country+0.19+0.140.23342moderate
Active labour market spending and Environment scoreAlmost no link either way. Environment score by country-0.01+0.140.56142moderate
Active labour market spending and Armed conflict presentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Armed conflict present by country-0.33-0.140.39642moderate
Active labour market spending and Regulatory qualityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Regulatory quality by country+0.45+0.140.48042proxy
Active labour market spending and Male labor participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Male labor participation by country-0.23-0.130.24842independent
Active labour market spending and Women in a unionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women in a union by country+0.17+0.130.15342moderate
Active labour market spending and Government spending per capitaCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government spending per capita by country+0.45+0.130.57141proxy
Active labour market spending and Fixed broadbandCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Fixed broadband by country+0.40+0.130.28842proxy
Active labour market spending and Age at childbearingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Age at childbearing by country+0.42+0.130.45042moderate
Active labour market spending and Unemployment benefit spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Unemployment benefit spending by country+0.23+0.120.64339moderate
Active labour market spending and FDI inflowsAlmost no link either way. FDI inflows by country-0.08+0.120.59742independent
Active labour market spending and Life expectancyCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Life expectancy by country+0.36+0.110.52442proxy
Active labour market spending and Gender wage gapCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender wage gap by country-0.14-0.110.67138independent
Active labour market spending and Market-income GiniAlmost no link either way. Market-income Gini by country+0.01+0.110.37440moderate
Active labour market spending and Gini indexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gini index by country-0.35-0.110.67141moderate
Active labour market spending and Free and fair electionsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Free and fair elections by country+0.30+0.100.26542high
Active labour market spending and Migrant share of populationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Migrant share of population by country+0.25-0.100.35242high
Active labour market spending and Marriage rate (UN)Almost no link either way. Marriage rate (UN) by country-0.00-0.100.49641independent
Active labour market spending and Out of school, primaryCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Out of school, primary by country-0.19-0.100.53142moderate
Active labour market spending and Muslim shareCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Muslim share by country-0.10-0.100.24342independent
Active labour market spending and Birth rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Birth rate by country-0.21-0.090.70242proxy
Active labour market spending and Confidence in religious institutionsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Confidence in religious institutions by country-0.19-0.090.69140moderate
Active labour market spending and UndernourishmentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Undernourishment by country-0.19+0.090.68141proxy
Active labour market spending and Equality scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Equality score by country+0.34+0.080.73541high
Active labour market spending and Life satisfactionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Life satisfaction by country+0.30+0.080.56542proxy
Active labour market spending and Trust in governmentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Trust in government by country+0.34+0.080.69942moderate
Active labour market spending and Employment in agricultureCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Employment in agriculture by country-0.40-0.080.76142proxy
Active labour market spending and Electricity accessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Electricity access by country+0.22-0.080.56342high
Active labour market spending and Under-5 mortalityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Under-5 mortality by country-0.39-0.080.69742proxy
Active labour market spending and Female labor participationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Female labor participation by country+0.23+0.080.65342independent
Active labour market spending and Women ministersCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Women ministers by country+0.16+0.070.40042independent
Active labour market spending and Infant mortalityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Infant mortality by country-0.38-0.070.72642proxy
Active labour market spending and Hospital bedsAlmost no link either way. Hospital beds by country-0.01-0.070.67842high
Active labour market spending and Tertiary enrollmentAlmost no link either way. Tertiary enrollment by country+0.07+0.070.46642high
Active labour market spending and PISA scienceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. PISA science by country+0.24-0.070.68142high
Active labour market spending and Gender Development IndexCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Gender Development Index by country+0.15+0.070.67142high
Active labour market spending and Inequality-adjusted HDICould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Inequality-adjusted HDI by country+0.43+0.070.58442proxy
Active labour market spending and UrbanizationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Urbanization by country+0.14+0.060.76642high
Active labour market spending and Infrastructure scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Infrastructure score by country+0.39+0.060.53742proxy
Active labour market spending and Internet usersCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Internet users by country+0.33-0.060.59742proxy
Active labour market spending and Compulsory schoolingAlmost no link either way. Compulsory schooling by country-0.07+0.060.76342moderate
Active labour market spending and Out-of-pocket health spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Out-of-pocket health spending by country-0.31-0.060.78742moderate
Active labour market spending and Pupil-teacher ratioCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Pupil-teacher ratio by country-0.32-0.060.54540proxy
Active labour market spending and Corporate tax rateAlmost no link either way. Corporate tax rate by country-0.09-0.060.78340moderate
Active labour market spending and HIV prevalenceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. HIV prevalence by country-0.33-0.060.73632moderate
Active labour market spending and Refugees originatingAlmost no link either way. Refugees originating by country-0.07+0.060.64342moderate
Active labour market spending and Political stabilityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political stability by country+0.21-0.050.84142moderate
Active labour market spending and Child stuntingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Child stunting by country-0.40-0.050.83125proxy
Active labour market spending and Government effectivenessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Government effectiveness by country+0.41+0.050.85542proxy
Active labour market spending and Alcohol consumptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Alcohol consumption by country+0.22+0.050.74442moderate
Active labour market spending and Protected landAlmost no link either way. Protected land by country+0.01+0.050.77642independent
Active labour market spending and Population growthCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Population growth by country+0.16+0.050.67642moderate
Active labour market spending and Fertility rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Fertility rate by country-0.14-0.050.87642proxy
Active labour market spending and Birth registrationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Birth registration by country+0.30-0.050.83141proxy
Active labour market spending and Women in managementAlmost no link either way. Women in management by country-0.05+0.050.80339moderate
Active labour market spending and Primary completionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Primary completion by country+0.22-0.050.88841proxy
Active labour market spending and Mobile subscriptionsAlmost no link either way. Mobile subscriptions by country-0.04+0.040.85642moderate
Active labour market spending and Conflict deathsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Conflict deaths by country-0.25-0.040.76542moderate
Active labour market spending and Adolescent fertilityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Adolescent fertility by country-0.32+0.040.81542proxy
Active labour market spending and Informal employmentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Informal employment by country-0.42-0.040.69136proxy
Active labour market spending and Forest areaCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Forest area by country-0.12+0.040.77042independent
Active labour market spending and Food insecurityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Food insecurity by country-0.37-0.030.83941proxy
Active labour market spending and HDICould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. HDI by country+0.42+0.030.87442proxy
Active labour market spending and Children with one parentAlmost no link either way. Children with one parent by country+0.07+0.030.90736independent
Active labour market spending and Recycling rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Recycling rate by country+0.28+0.030.86335moderate
Active labour market spending and Religiously unaffiliatedCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Religiously unaffiliated by country+0.13-0.030.90042moderate
Active labour market spending and Vulnerable employmentCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Vulnerable employment by country-0.34+0.030.93542proxy
Active labour market spending and Slum share of urban populationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Slum share of urban population by country-0.30-0.030.68641high
Active labour market spending and Basic water accessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Basic water access by country+0.10-0.020.87442proxy
Active labour market spending and Health spendingCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Health spending by country+0.21+0.020.96342independent
Active labour market spending and Premature NCD mortalityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Premature NCD mortality by country-0.20-0.020.87442high
Active labour market spending and DTP3 immunisationCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. DTP3 immunisation by country+0.15-0.020.82642moderate
Active labour market spending and Homicide rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Homicide rate by country-0.31-0.020.89742moderate
Active labour market spending and Suicide rateCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Suicide rate by country+0.15-0.020.89242independent
Active labour market spending and Political corruptionCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Political corruption by country-0.33-0.020.90442high
Active labour market spending and Divorce rate (UN)Almost no link either way. Divorce rate (UN) by country+0.04+0.020.88439independent
Active labour market spending and Tuberculosis incidenceCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Tuberculosis incidence by country-0.29-0.010.95042high
Active labour market spending and Education scoreCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Education score by country+0.19-0.010.95842proxy
Active labour market spending and PISA mathsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. PISA maths by country+0.33-0.010.95942high
Active labour market spending and Anaemia in womenCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Anaemia in women by country-0.17-0.010.98742high
Active labour market spending and Self-reported happinessCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Self-reported happiness by country+0.21-0.000.97240moderate
Active labour market spending and Maternal mortalityCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. Maternal mortality by country-0.33-0.000.99442proxy
Active labour market spending and One-person householdsCould easily be chance once only countries with similar income are compared. One-person households by country+0.27+0.000.99834high
Active labour market spending and GDP per capita (PPP)One side of this pair is national income itself, the thing the other figures adjust for. Adjusting income for income leaves nothing, so there is no adjusted figure. The unadjusted link shows how closely the other measure follows income. GDP per capita (PPP) by country+0.46——42proxy
Active labour market spending and GNI per capita (PPP)One side of this pair is national income itself, the thing the other figures adjust for. Adjusting income for income leaves nothing, so there is no adjusted figure. The unadjusted link shows how closely the other measure follows income. GNI per capita (PPP) by country+0.45——42proxy
Active labour market spending and GDP per capita (market)One side of this pair is national income itself, the thing the other figures adjust for. Adjusting income for income leaves nothing, so there is no adjusted figure. The unadjusted link shows how closely the other measure follows income. GDP per capita (market) by country+0.40——42proxy

Source

OECD · via Our World in Data

CC BY 4.0 (OECD terms and conditions) · licence terms · updated annual, except the snapshots noted per indicator

OECD databases as named on each indicator: PISA, Social Expenditure Database (SOCX), Income Distribution Database, Development Assistance Committee statistics, Family Database, Government at a Glance, Corporate Tax Statistics, employment and environment statistics